Secretarial audit under Section 204
A practising company secretary audits the year's compliance and reports on Form MR-3, annexed to the board's report. Listed companies and their material unlisted subsidiaries, larger public companies, and any company with ₹100 crore of bank borrowings need one.
- Who needs one
- Listed companies and their material unlisted subsidiaries; public companies with ₹50 crore paid-up capital or ₹250 crore turnover; any company with ₹100 crore borrowed from banks or public financial institutions.
- The report
- Form MR-3, annexed to the board's report and filed with the financial statements on AOC-4.
- If it is missed
- A penalty of ₹2 lakh each on the company, every officer in default and the company secretary in practice in default.
One audit, from appointment to filing
The audit covers a financial year and is filed with that year's accounts.
Before the audit
Auditor appointed
By the board; for a listed company, by shareholders at the AGM on the board's recommendation.
Through the year
Records checked
Minutes, registers, Registrar filings, FEMA reporting and the laws specific to the business.
After year-end
MR-3 signed
By a practising company secretary with a valid ICSI peer review certificate.
Board's report
Remarks explained
The board explains in full every qualification or remark in the report.
Within 30 days of the AGM
Filed with AOC-4
The board's report, with MR-3, goes to the Registrar with the accounts.
What we handle
Whether you need one
Paid-up capital, turnover and bank borrowings tested on the latest audited financial statements.
Rule 9
The secretarial audit
A review of the year's compliance under the Companies Act, FEMA, the depositories rules and the laws specific to the business, reported on MR-3.
Section 204
Material subsidiaries of listed companies
A material unlisted Indian subsidiary of a listed company needs its own secretarial audit by a peer-reviewed company secretary.
Regulation 24A
Annual secretarial compliance report
For listed entities, signed only by the secretarial auditor or another eligible peer-reviewed company secretary.
Regulation 24A(2)
What an MR-3 covers, law by law
Companies Act, 2013
We check the year's board and general meetings, appointments, share allotments and Registrar filings against the registers, and note every form that went in late.
Section 204
Secretarial Standards
Notice periods, quorum, minutes and the conduct of the AGM are tested against the two standards the ICSI issues for board and general meetings.
SS-1, SS-2
Foreign exchange laws
Each remittance is matched to its report: FC-GPR, FC-TRS, the FLA return, ECB-2 returns and any overseas investment reporting.
FEMA, 1999
Securities and depository laws
For a company with shares in demat, we check the ISIN, the half-yearly PAS-6 and the depository records.
A listed company is also tested against SEBI's regulations.
Depositories Act, 1996
Laws specific to the business
We agree with the management which other laws apply to the business, such as labour, environmental or sector licensing laws, and MR-3 names them.
Form MR-3
The board's answer
The board must explain in full every qualification or remark in its own report.
We draft the observations so the directors can respond to each one.
Section 204(3)
Material subsidiaries of a listed company
We test whether the subsidiary's turnover or net worth is over 10% of the listed group's consolidated figure for the preceding year, which makes it material.
Regulation 16(1)(c)
Filing with the accounts
MR-3 is annexed to the board's report and goes to the Registrar on AOC-4.
We check that the annexure is attached before the form is uploaded.
AOC-4
From the board's resolution to the Registrar's filing
The report has to reach the board before it approves its own annual report, so we ask for the records as soon as the year ends. A listed company follows the same steps with two additions.
01
Auditor appointed and the laws listed
At appointment
For a listed company, shareholders appoint at the AGM on the board's recommendation; for other companies the board appoints.
The laws specific to the business are agreed.
02
Records kept audit-ready
Through the year
Minutes signed, registers current, and each FEMA report filed within its limit, so that nothing waits for year-end.
03
Records requested and checked
After 31 March
Registers, minutes, e-form acknowledgements, FEMA reports and the business-specific licences, checked against the dates the law sets.
04
Observations shared
Before the report is signed
The management sees each observation, so the board can prepare its answer to it.
05
MR-3 signed
Before the board's report is approved
By a practising company secretary with a valid peer review certificate on the day the UDIN is generated.
06
Annual secretarial compliance report
By 30 May, for listed companies
Filed with the stock exchanges within 60 days of the year-end.
07
Filed with AOC-4
Within 30 days of the AGM
MR-3 goes to the Registrar as part of the board's report, with the accounts.
Records the company hands over for the audit
The auditor works from the company's own records and reports what they show.
Registers and minutes
- Minutes of every board and committee meeting, with attendance
- Minutes of general meetings, with the notice and proof of dispatch
- Registers of members (Section 88), directors and key managerial personnel (Section 170), charges (Section 85) and contracts with related parties (Section 189)
Filings for the year
- Acknowledgements for every e-form: AOC-4, MGT-7, DIR-12, MGT-14, PAS-3 and ADT-1
- The previous year's board's report and annual return
- Directors' disclosures: DIR-8 and MBP-1
Foreign exchange and securities
- FC-GPR and FC-TRS acknowledgements, with the remittance advice for each
- The FLA return and ECB-2 returns, where they apply
- Share allotment and transfer records, and the PAS-6 filings and ISIN details if the shares are in demat
For the business-specific laws
- Licences, registrations and renewals the business holds
- Returns filed under those laws during the year
- The management's written confirmation of compliance with them
Where companies pick up qualifications in MR-3
Forms filed after the 30-day mark
DIR-12 and MGT-14 fall due 30 days after the appointment or the resolution, and PAS-3 within 15 days of a private placement.
Paying the additional fee closes the filing, but the delay is still in the Registrar's record for the auditor to note.
Sections 42, 117 and 170
Meetings that run past the legal gaps
Most companies must hold at least four board meetings a year, with no more than 120 days between two of them, and the AGM within six months of the year-end.
A gap in either shows up in the report.
Sections 173(1) and 96(1)
Remittances without a matching report
Each allotment or share transfer is traced to its FC-GPR or FC-TRS.
A report that is missing or late appears in MR-3, and the board must explain it.
FEMA, 1999
A remark the board's report does not answer
The board must explain every qualification or remark in full.
The explanation sits in the board's report next to MR-3, so a missing answer is visible to anyone who reads the filing.
Section 204(3)
A listed company's auditor appointed for under five years
The term cannot be shorter than five years, and the appointment is made by shareholders at the AGM, not by the board alone.
A casual vacancy must be filled by the board within three months.
Regulation 24A(1)
The wrong partner signing, or a lapsed peer review
A firm's report is signed only by a partner who is a peer-reviewed company secretary, and the certificate must be valid on the day the UDIN is generated.
Regulation 24A(1A)
What the secretarial audit fee depends on
These are the points we ask about on the first call before quoting.
- Which test brings the company in: listed, material subsidiary, public company thresholds, or ₹100 crore of bank borrowings
- How many laws apply to the business beyond the Companies Act and FEMA
- How many board and general meetings, and how many e-forms, the company had in the year
- How many FEMA reports the year's allotments, transfers and borrowings gave rise to
- Whether one auditor covers a listed parent and its material subsidiary, or the company needs the annual secretarial compliance report as well
- Whether we are asked for other work, which for a listed company needs board approval and cannot include internal audit or outsourced compliance
Questions India teams ask
- Is a secretarial audit mandatory for a private company?
- Usually only in two cases: its outstanding loans or borrowings from banks or public financial institutions are ₹100 crore or more on its latest audited financial statements, or it is a material unlisted Indian subsidiary of a listed company. The capital and turnover tests apply to public companies.
- Who can conduct a secretarial audit?
- A company secretary in practice. ICSI also requires the auditor to hold a valid peer review certificate on the day the report's UDIN is generated.
- What is the penalty for not having one?
- Under Section 204(4), ₹2 lakh each on the company, every officer in default and the company secretary in practice in default.
- How long can a listed company keep the same secretarial auditor?
- From 1 April 2025, one term of five consecutive years for an individual and two terms for a firm, then five years' cooling-off. Service before 31 March 2025 does not count.
- Can a listed company's secretarial auditor do other work for it?
- Only with board approval, and never internal audit, compliance systems design, outsourced compliance or record-keeping, investment advice, investment banking, or management services, for the company, its holding company or its subsidiaries.
Related
Talk to Vandana about your Indian entity
or email [email protected]




