Updated
Whole-time company secretary: who must appoint one under Rule 8A
Under Section 203 of the Companies Act, 2013, every listed company, every public company with ₹10 crore or more of paid-up share capital and every private company with ₹10 crore or more must have a whole-time company secretary. Each appointment and each exit is reported on Form DIR-12 within 30 days.
- Who
- Listed companies and public companies with ₹10 crore or more of paid-up share capital (Rule 8). Private companies with ₹10 crore or more (Rule 8A).
- Threshold
- ₹10 crore of paid-up share capital. Under Rule 8A it applies to financial years starting on or after 1 April 2020. Before that, Rule 8A named a company outside Rule 8 at ₹5 crore, from 9 June 2014.
- Vacancy
- A vacancy in the post is filled by a board meeting within six months (Section 203(4)).
- Form
- DIR-12 within 30 days of the appointment, and again within 30 days of the person leaving.
From the balance sheet to DIR-12
The test is paid-up share capital. The appointment is a board decision, and the Registrar is told within 30 days.
Each year-end
Read the paid-up capital
The audited balance sheet shows paid-up share capital. The company is checked as listed, public or private.
At ₹10 crore
The rule applies
Rule 8 covers every listed company and every other public company with ₹10 crore or more. Rule 8A covers private companies with ₹10 crore or more.
Board meeting
Appoint by resolution
The resolution sets out the terms, including remuneration, under Section 203(2).
Within 30 days
DIR-12 filed
The Registrar receives the particulars of the appointment. A vacancy later is filled within six months.
What the rule covers, and what stays with a practising company secretary
Whether the rule applies
A listed company, a public company with ₹10 crore or more of paid-up share capital, or a private company with ₹10 crore or more, must have a whole-time company secretary.
Section 203(1), Rules 8 and 8A
The threshold and its history
Rule 8A was inserted on 9 June 2014 at ₹5 crore. It was substituted on 3 January 2020 and now names private companies at ₹10 crore.
G.S.R. 390(E), G.S.R. 13(E)
Appointment
By a board resolution that states the terms and remuneration.
A whole-time key managerial person holds office in one company only, apart from its subsidiary.
Section 203(2) and (3)
Filling a vacancy
The board fills the vacancy at a board meeting within six months of the date it arose.
Section 203(4)
DIR-12
Particulars of the appointment, and of the cessation, filed with the Registrar within 30 days and certified by a professional in practice.
Section 170(2), DIR-12
Certifications for a company below the threshold
A company with no whole-time company secretary can still need a practising company secretary for MGT-7, MGT-8 and secretarial audit.
Section 92, Rule 11(2), Section 204
What we do: test the rule, advise the board on the appointment, file DIR-12 and certify what needs a company secretary in practice
Does the rule apply to this company
We read the latest audited balance sheet for paid-up share capital and confirm whether the company is listed, public or private.
We then apply Rule 8 or Rule 8A and put the answer in writing for the board, with the date of the balance sheet it rests on.
Rules 8 and 8A
Companies close to the line
Rule 8A has no Explanation fixing the date for measuring capital.
We tell the board before an allotment, a rights issue or a conversion takes paid-up capital to ₹10 crore, so the post is planned before the balance sheet shows the crossing.
Rule 8A
The role and the appointment terms
We help the board settle the role and the terms, and check the ICSI membership details of the person the company has chosen.
The whole-time company secretary is the company's own appointee. We are a firm in practice and do not act as a company's whole-time company secretary, and we do not recruit staff.
Section 203(1), DIR-12
The board resolution
We draft the resolution and the appointment letter.
Section 203(2) asks for the terms and conditions, including remuneration, in the resolution.
Section 203(2)
DIR-12 for the appointment
We prepare the form and its attachments, and certify it as the professional in practice where the company asks us to.
It goes to the Registrar within 30 days of the appointment.
Section 170(2), DIR-12
Induction
We brief the new company secretary on the registers, the compliance calendar, the open filings and the list of what is due in the first year, so the work does not depend on one person's memory.
Certifications that need a company secretary in practice
A whole-time company secretary does not replace these.
We certify the annual return in MGT-8 where Rule 11(2) applies, sign MGT-7 where a company has no company secretary, and carry out secretarial audit where Section 204 applies.
Section 92, Rule 11(2), Section 204
From the balance sheet test to the first months of the new company secretary
The 30 days for DIR-12 run from the appointment, and the six months for a vacancy run from the day the post fell vacant.
01
Test the company against the rule
At each balance sheet
Paid-up share capital is read from the audited financial statements. A listed company is covered whatever its capital.
02
Settle the role
Before the appointment
The board decides the terms.
A whole-time key managerial person cannot hold office in another company, except a subsidiary, so a shared or part-time arrangement does not meet the rule.
03
Check the candidate's standing
Before the offer
The membership number is checked against the ICSI database as associate or fellow.
A member who holds a certificate of practice is in practice, and DIR-12 has been reported to reject such a number, so that status is checked before the appointment.
04
Pass the resolution
Board meeting
The board appoints the company secretary by resolution that sets out the terms and remuneration.
The appointment letter follows the resolution.
05
File DIR-12
Within 30 days
The form is digitally signed for the company and certified by a chartered accountant, cost accountant or company secretary in practice.
The fee is under the Registration Offices and Fees Rules.
06
Hand over the records
First months
The registers, minute books, calendar and pending filings are handed over, with the dates of what falls due next.
07
Fill it within six months
If the post falls vacant
The board fills the vacancy at a meeting within six months, and the exit is reported on DIR-12 within 30 days of the cessation.
What the board, the candidate and the finance team provide
The balance sheet decides whether the rule applies. The candidate's membership details and the resolution carry the appointment.
From the company
- Latest audited financial statements, showing paid-up share capital
- Certificate of incorporation, and whether the company is listed, public or private
- Names of the existing directors and key managerial personnel
- The terms offered, including remuneration
From the candidate
- ICSI membership number, and whether associate or fellow
- A statement that the person holds no certificate of practice
- A statement that the person holds no whole-time key managerial office in another company, other than a subsidiary
- Release letter from the present employer
For the appointment
- Board resolution appointing the company secretary, with the terms and remuneration
- Appointment letter
- Digital signature certificate of the person who signs the form for the company
- Membership number and certificate of practice number of the professional who certifies DIR-12
When the company secretary leaves
- Resignation letter, or the board's order if the company ended the appointment
- Evidence of cessation, which DIR-12 asks for as an attachment
- The date the person ceased, which sets the 30 days
Where companies read the rule wrongly, and where the appointment turns late
The old ₹5 crore figure
Rule 8A as inserted on 9 June 2014 said ₹5 crore.
The Amendment Rules, 2020 substituted it with ₹10 crore for financial years commencing on or after 1 April 2020. A page that gives ₹5 crore describes the rule before that date.
G.S.R. 390(E), G.S.R. 13(E)
Private companies are covered
Rule 8 names listed and public companies.
Rule 8A, as now worded, names every private company with ₹10 crore or more of paid-up share capital. A source that says private companies are not covered reads Rule 8 alone.
Rules 8 and 8A
An unlisted public company under ₹10 crore
Before 2020, Rule 8A covered a company outside Rule 8 from ₹5 crore, which reached these companies.
The present text names private companies only, and Rule 8 starts at ₹10 crore for public companies. Read on its words, neither rule names an unlisted public company below ₹10 crore. We check the current consolidated text before we advise on one.
Rules 8 and 8A
The date for measuring capital
The 2020 notification added an Explanation to Rule 9(1) that takes paid-up capital on the last date of the latest audited financial statement.
It says it applies to that sub-rule. Rule 8A has no such explanation, so the date is not written into the rule. A company near ₹10 crore should settle the question with its professional before the balance sheet is signed.
Rule 9(1), Explanation; Rule 8A
Paid-up capital is not authorised capital or net worth
The Act defines paid-up share capital as the amount credited as paid up on shares issued, and it leaves out other amounts received on the shares, whatever they are called.
Securities premium and reserves are not part of it.
Section 2(64)
A shared or practising company secretary
A whole-time key managerial person holds office in one company, apart from its subsidiary.
A practising company secretary or firm can certify the company's filings but does not fill the post, and DIR-12 has been reported to reject a membership number that holds a certificate of practice.
Section 203(3), DIR-12
A vacancy left open
The board has six months from the date of the vacancy.
Past that, the company is in default of Section 203. The penalty is ₹5 lakh on the company and ₹50,000 on each director and key managerial person in default, with ₹1,000 for each day after the first, up to ₹5 lakh.
Section 203(4) and (5)
DIR-12 filed late
The form is due within 30 days of the appointment or the cessation.
Each late filing pays the normal fee multiplied by a factor that rises with the days of delay.
Section 170(2), Registration Offices and Fees Rules
The government fee for DIR-12, and the penalty for default
These are the Registrar's fee and the penalty in the Act. They are separate from anything we charge, and fees can change, so the MCA portal has the current amount.
- DIR-12 normal fee, by the company's nominal share capital: ₹200 below ₹1 lakh, ₹300 from ₹1 lakh to ₹4,99,999, ₹400 from ₹5 lakh to ₹24,99,999, ₹500 from ₹25 lakh to ₹99,99,999 and ₹600 at ₹1 crore or more. A company with no share capital pays ₹200
- Late DIR-12, additional fee on top of the normal fee: 2 times up to 30 days late, 4 times up to 60 days, 6 times up to 90 days, 10 times up to 180 days and 12 times beyond that
- Penalty under Section 203(5) for a default, including a vacancy left past six months: ₹5 lakh on the company, ₹50,000 on each director and key managerial person in default, and ₹1,000 for each day after the first, up to ₹5 lakh
Questions India teams ask
- Does a private company need a whole-time company secretary?
- Yes, if its paid-up share capital is ₹10 crore or more. Rule 8A says every private company with that much paid-up capital shall have a whole-time company secretary. A private company below ₹10 crore is not required to have one.
- Was the threshold ₹5 crore, and what changed?
- Rule 8A was inserted by G.S.R. 390(E) on 9 June 2014 and covered a company outside Rule 8 with ₹5 crore or more. G.S.R. 13(E) of 3 January 2020 substituted it. It now reads: every private company with paid-up share capital of ten crore rupees or more shall have a whole-time company secretary. It applies to financial years commencing on or after 1 April 2020.
- Does an unlisted public company below ₹10 crore need one?
- Rule 8 covers listed companies and public companies with ₹10 crore or more. Rule 8A, as now worded, names private companies. On the words, an unlisted public company below ₹10 crore is not named by either. Companies in that position should have the current text checked.
- On which date is paid-up capital measured?
- Rule 8A does not say. An Explanation added to Rule 9(1) in 2020 takes capital on the last date of the latest audited financial statement, but it is limited to that sub-rule. The latest audited balance sheet is the natural working measure, but the rule does not require it.
- How long does the company have to fill a vacancy?
- Six months from the date the post fell vacant. Section 203(4) asks the board to fill it at a board meeting within that period. The exit is also reported on DIR-12 within 30 days of the cessation.
- What is the penalty for not appointing one?
- Under Section 203(5), as substituted by the Companies (Amendment) Act, 2019, the company is liable to a penalty of ₹5 lakh. Each director and key managerial person in default is liable to ₹50,000, with ₹1,000 for each day after the first, up to ₹5 lakh.
- Is DIR-12 filed for a resignation as well?
- Yes. DIR-12 reports appointments, cessations and changes in designation of directors and key managerial personnel, within 30 days of the event. For a cessation, the form asks for evidence of it as an attachment.
- What does a company below the threshold still need a company secretary for?
- Section 92(1) has the annual return in MGT-7 signed by a director and the company secretary, or by a director and a company secretary in practice where there is no company secretary. A One Person Company or small company has its own signing rule. A listed company, or one with paid-up capital of ₹10 crore or more or turnover of ₹50 crore or more, also needs a practising company secretary's certificate in MGT-8. Secretarial audit under Section 204 has its own thresholds.
Sources
- Companies Act, 2013 (India Code): Sections 2(64), 92, 170 and 203
- Companies (Appointment and Remuneration of Managerial Personnel) Rules, 2014 and amendments (MCA rules index)
- MCA notification of 3 January 2020 (G.S.R. 13(E)): Amendment Rules, 2020, substituting Rule 8A
- MCA instruction kit: Form DIR-12
- Companies Act, 2013, Section 92 (annual return and certification by a company secretary in practice)
Related
Talk to Vandana about your Indian entity
or email [email protected]




