Updated
BEN-2: significant beneficial ownership under Section 90
A company finds the individuals who ultimately hold 10 percent or more of it, or control it. They declare on BEN-1, the company files BEN-2 with the Registrar within 30 days, and it records them in register BEN-3.
- Who is covered
- An individual with 10 percent or more of the shares, voting rights or dividends, indirectly or with direct holdings, or with significant influence or control.
- Deadlines
- BEN-1 within 30 days of becoming one or of a change. BEN-2 within 30 days of receiving it.
- Register
- BEN-3, kept by the company and open to members.
From a foreign parent to the individual behind it
The company traces upward until it reaches individuals, then files what they declare.
First
Notice to members
Every member that is not an individual and holds 10 percent or more is sent a notice on BEN-4.
Then
Traced through the group
Each body corporate member, in India or abroad, is looked through to the individual who holds more than half of it, or of its ultimate holding company.
Within 30 days
BEN-1 from the individual
The individual declares to the company, within 30 days of becoming a significant beneficial owner or of a change.
Within 30 days of receipt
BEN-2 filed
The company files the return with the Registrar.
Always
Register kept
Register BEN-3 is kept up to date.
What we handle
Notice to members
BEN-4 sent to each member that is not an individual and holds 10 percent or more of the shares, voting rights or dividends.
BEN-4, Rule 2A
Tracing a foreign parent
A foreign member is looked through to the individual who holds a majority stake in it or in its ultimate holding company.
Control and significant influence are tested separately, and we document the conclusion either way.
Rule 2(1)(h)
BEN-1 declarations
Collected from each individual, in India or abroad, with the details the form asks for.
BEN-1
BEN-2 return
Filed within 30 days of receiving the declaration.
The form revised on 15 July 2024 also reports a change in an existing owner's particulars.
BEN-2
Register of owners
Kept in Form BEN-3 and open to members for inspection on working days.
BEN-3
Indian holding companies
Shares held by an Indian holding company that is itself a reporting company are left out, and its details go in BEN-2.
A foreign parent is not a reporting company, so it is looked through.
Rule 8
What we do from the first notice to the BEN-3 register
Who counts
We apply the 10 percent test to shares, voting rights and dividend rights, held indirectly or together with any direct holding, for every member of the company.
We run the separate test for significant influence or control alongside it.
Rule 2(1)(h)
Notice to members
We send BEN-4 to each member that is not an individual and holds 10 percent or more of the shares, voting rights or dividends, and follow up for the reply.
Rule 2A, BEN-4
Tracing the foreign parent
We trace upward through each body corporate, in India or abroad, until we reach the individual who holds more than half of it or of its ultimate holding company.
We write down the chain and keep the evidence.
Rule 2(1)(h)
Control and significant influence
We test whether an individual controls the parent or influences the Indian company through board appointment rights, shareholders' agreements or voting arrangements.
We record the conclusion whether it is yes or no.
Rule 2(1)(h)
BEN-1 from each individual
We prepare the declaration for each individual to sign, including those abroad.
The form asks for a passport number in the case of a foreign national.
BEN-1
BEN-2 return
We file BEN-2 with the Registrar within 30 days of the company receiving each declaration.
The revised form of July 2024 also reports a change in an existing owner's particulars.
Rule 4, BEN-2
Register BEN-3
We keep the register up to date. It is open to members for inspection on working days.
Rule 5, BEN-3
Nominee shares
We check whether Section 89 declarations are also due for the nominee's share, on MGT-4 and MGT-5 to the company and MGT-6 to the Registrar.
They are separate from BEN-2.
Section 89
From the BEN-4 notice to the BEN-2 and the register
The slower part is usually on the parent's side: finding who sits at the top of the chain, and getting a declaration signed abroad.
01
Members listed
First
Every member, with the share of capital, voting rights and dividends it holds. We note which holders are nominees.
02
BEN-4 sent
Then
Each member that is not an individual and holds 10 percent or more gets the notice.
03
The chain traced
On the reply
The parent gives its structure up to the individuals.
At each step we test for more than half of the equity, the voting rights or the right to dividends.
04
Control tested
Alongside
Board appointment rights, shareholders' agreements and voting agreements are read for control or significant influence, apart from the percentage test.
05
BEN-1 signed
Within 30 days
An individual declares within 30 days of becoming a significant beneficial owner, or of a change in the ownership.
06
BEN-2 filed
Within 30 days of receipt
The company files the return and enters the owner in register BEN-3.
07
Changes watched
Afterwards
A change higher up the parent's chain can change an individual's indirect holding. We re-run the test when we hear of one.
What the parent and each individual provide
A chart of the group is the first paper we ask for. Everything else follows from it.
From the foreign parent
- A structure chart up to the individuals, with the percentage of equity, voting rights and dividend rights at each step
- The register of shareholders, or the equivalent, of the parent and of each holding company above it
- Shareholders' agreements, voting agreements and board nomination rights that bear on control of the parent or the Indian company
- Whether the parent is listed, and whether any one individual holds more than half of it
- The names of the directors the parent has nominated to the Indian board
From each significant beneficial owner
- Name, date of birth, nationality, address and email, as BEN-1 asks
- Passport number, in the case of a foreign national
- The shares in which the interest is held, with the class, number and percentage
- The date the interest arose or changed
- The signed BEN-1
From the company
- The register of members, with the nominee's holding
- The BEN-4 notices sent and the replies
- The existing register BEN-3 and earlier BEN-2 acknowledgements
Where the penalties under Section 90 come from
Stopping at the parent
A parent is a body corporate, not an individual.
The company must take steps to identify the individuals behind it. An answer of none, without a trace up the chain, leaves the duty open.
Section 90(4A)
A declaration with no return
A company that does not file the return, keep the register, take the steps to identify owners or allow inspection is liable to ₹1 lakh, and ₹500 for each day after the first, up to ₹5 lakh.
Each officer in default is liable to ₹25,000, and ₹200 for each day after the first, up to ₹1 lakh.
Section 90(11)
An individual who does not declare
An individual who fails to declare is liable to ₹50,000, and ₹1,000 for each day after the first, up to ₹2 lakh.
A wilfully false or incorrect declaration, or suppressing material information, makes the person liable to action under Section 447.
Section 90(10) and (12)
A notice that is not followed up
The person given the notice has 30 days to reply.
If there is no reply, or the company is not satisfied, the company applies to the Tribunal within 15 days after that period. The Tribunal can restrict transfer, dividends and voting.
Section 90(5) to (8)
A change that was never reported
A change higher up the parent's chain can change an individual's indirect holding.
The individual declares within 30 days, and the company files BEN-2 within 30 days of receiving it.
Rules 2A and 4
BEN-2 taken for MGT-6
Section 89 asks the registered holder and the beneficial owner to declare to the company, and the company to file a return on MGT-6.
Filing BEN-2 does not cover them.
Section 89
What the fee depends on
These are the points we ask about on the first call before quoting.
- How many layers and countries lie between the Indian company and the individuals
- Whether the parent is widely held or listed, or held through trusts, partnerships or funds
- How many individuals have to sign a BEN-1
- How much of the parent's constitutional and ownership paper must be collected from abroad
- Whether BEN-4 replies come slowly, or a Tribunal application is needed
- Whether we also keep register BEN-3 and watch for changes through the year
Questions India teams ask
- Who is a significant beneficial owner?
- An individual who, alone or with others, holds indirectly or together with direct holdings 10 percent or more of the shares, voting rights or dividends, or who has the right to exercise, or actually exercises, significant influence or control other than through direct holdings alone.
- What are BEN-1, BEN-2, BEN-3 and BEN-4?
- BEN-1 is the individual's declaration to the company. BEN-2 is the company's return to the Registrar. BEN-3 is the register of owners. BEN-4 is the company's notice to a member asking for information.
- How is a foreign parent's ownership traced?
- Where a member is a body corporate, in India or abroad, an individual counts if they hold a majority stake in it or in its ultimate holding company. A majority stake is more than half of the equity, the voting rights or the right to dividends.
- Does a wholly owned subsidiary of a listed foreign parent file BEN-2?
- The duty to find out applies to every company. If no individual qualifies, there is no BEN-1 to receive and no BEN-2 to file, and we keep the enquiry on file.
- What are the deadlines?
- An individual who becomes a significant beneficial owner, or whose ownership changes, declares on BEN-1 within 30 days. The company files BEN-2 within 30 days of receiving it.
- What if an owner does not reply to the notice?
- The company applies to the Tribunal under Section 90(7), which can restrict the shares: no transfer, no dividend and no voting rights.
- Is this the same test as the land-border rule?
- No. Section 90 and the Rules ask for individuals at 10 percent or control. The land-border approval rule for foreign investment uses the beneficial owner as defined in the Prevention of Money-laundering Act. The two are checked separately.
- What changed in 2024?
- The Companies (Significant Beneficial Owners) Amendment Rules, 2024 (G.S.R. 404(E) of 15 July 2024) replaced Form BEN-2 with a form for the current MCA portal.
Sources
Related
Talk to Vandana about your Indian entity
or email [email protected]




